If you’ve spent any time on LoyalFans, you’ve probably noticed that not all visitors are created equal. Some are loyal supporters, some are just window shopping, and some are lurking in the shadows like a Wi-Fi signal thief. Understanding these three types—Subscribers, Followers, and Lurkers—is the key to maximizing your engagement and your earnings.
Let’s break them down.
Lurkers: The Ghosts in the Machine
Lurkers don’t have any icons or logos next to their name—just a blank space next to their profile picture.
They’re neither followers nor subscribers, meaning they haven’t even taken the bare minimum step of hitting the follow button. Yet, they’re still there. Watching. Liking. Occasionally spending.
What Can Lurkers See (and Not See)?
- No access to your feed unless you set posts to Public.
- No access to follower-only posts—they’d have to follow you first.
- No access to subscriber-only posts—they’d have to pay, assuming you set an unlock price for non-subscribers.
- Can still buy from your store—sometimes they’ll purchase content without committing to a subscription.
- Can still message you—which means you earn money if you’ve set higher message fees for non-followers. Which you probably should.
Are Lurkers Worth Your Time?
Most lurkers are just that—lurking. Nine times out of ten, they won’t spend a dime. But the other 10%? They might be this close to following or subscribing, just waiting for the right post or the right nudge. If they message you, they’re paying those sweet message fees, so setting non-follower rates higher than subscriber/follower rates is a smart move.
Lurkers might not be paying customers yet, but they do help boost your engagement metrics. And who knows? With the right content, they might just step out of the shadows.
Followers: The Window Shoppers
Followers are a step above lurkers—they’ve at least clicked the follow button, which means they’re interested, but not quite ready to subscribe. You can spot them by the LoyalFans logo in a red circle next to their name.
What Can Followers See?
- Public and follower-only posts, but not subscriber-only content.
- Your LoyalFans store, but without subscriber discounts (if you have any).
- Your DMs, but if you’ve set message fees, they’ll be charged accordingly.
How to Convert Followers into Subscribers:
- Tease them. Give just enough free content to keep them engaged, but make it clear that the real content is behind the paywall. Think teaser clips, polls, and posts that leave them wanting more.
- Engage with them. Reply to comments, like their interactions, and even send the occasional DM (if you feel like it). Making them feel seen can be the push they need to subscribe.
- Strategic messaging fees. Set follower message fees slightly lower than non-followers but higher than subscribers. This gives them an incentive to subscribe if they plan on messaging often.
Followers are the ones most likely to convert into paying subscribers—so don’t ignore them!
Subscribers: The MVPs
Subscribers are the ones paying every month (or whatever time allotted for the package they purchase). They put their money where their curiosity is, and in return, they get full access to your content. You can spot them by the yellow-gold circle with a medal in the middle next to their name.
What Can Subscribers See?
- Everything—public, follower-only, and subscriber-only posts.
- Exclusive discounts—you can set discounts for them in your LoyalFans store if you want.
- Lower messaging fees—if you set subscriber rates lower than non-followers, they get a perk for their commitment.
How to Keep Subscribers Happy (and Paying):
- Be consistent. Subscribers expect fresh content. If they’re paying monthly, they don’t want to see the same post they saw two weeks ago.
- Show appreciation. A quick thank-you message, a fun Q&A, or subscriber-only perks go a long way.
- Upsell wisely. Some subscribers are willing to pay extra for exclusive content, custom requests, or tips—don’t be afraid to offer premium add-ons.
Subscribers are your VIPs—treat them well, and they’ll stick around.
To Recap!
Every content creator has a mix of lurkers, followers, and subscribers—and understanding how to handle each one can turn more followers into subscribers and (hopefully) fewer lurkers into freeloaders.
- Lurkers boost engagement but rarely pay—unless they message you.
- Followers are interested but need a push—engagement and teasing work best.
- Subscribers are the real MVPs—keep them happy, and they’ll keep supporting you.
At the end of the day, your time and effort are valuable—so make sure you’re giving the most to the ones who give back.
Check out the rest of our LoyalFans Guides or go back to the BonerBlog!